To know, to utter, to argue ... and to archive and access

What place does archived online content have in social media's political discourse? Part 2 of 2

In my previous blog post I reflected upon web archiving as an ‘antidote to present shock’. In part, that post was inspired by an awareness that PANDORA web archive content was increasingly being cited (linked to) on social media, often for overt political purpose. In part, that post was also inspired by reports of UK Conservative Party’s attempt, albeit later retracted, to limit access to historical content from their website collected by and available at the Internet Archive. This was cause to pause and reflect upon our own web archiving efforts and how this operates within the everyday political discourse, particularly online and social media discourse. This, the second part to that original post, continues those musings and identifies current examples of archived sites finding their way into this political discourse.

Collecting and preserving online content for future long term access is for the most part a benign undertaking; perhaps, prima facie, as benign as collecting print publications, such as political memoirs and manifestos, and housing them securely among the august Library collections. However, three factors (at least) make this an assumption of which it is prudent to be wary, specifically: the selective process; the facility of online access; and the relentless ‘now’ of the online world and all that ensues from that (and which I discussed in the previous blog post).

Malcolm Turnbull website blog page

Federal Member for Wentworth Malcolm Turnbull blog page archived in PANDORA

Selectivity (with respect to what is included in the archive) is an issue because of the potential interpretations of the delivered outcomes of that selectivity. For example, assumptions or interpretation may be made as to why website 'x' is included and why websites 'y' and 'z' are not. Factors that complicate, constrain and determine selective collecting include limited resources, the need for timeliness in collecting, keeping up with new and changing content, requiring permissions to collect and preserve content, managing the risk of collecting contentious or dubious content and the technical limitations of the collecting mechanisms (the harvesting software and the rendering software). In summary, inclusion of certain content and the absence of other content does not represent an intention of bias.

The facility with which access to content is enabled online is certainly one factor that constantly threatens the benign character of the web archive collection. People can use the content and promote and disseminate it quickly and broadly in a manner that cannot be accomplished with print collections. So it becomes part of the discourse more easily and, certainly at times, more mischievously.

Consequently, provided there is open public access to the content – and that means efficient discovery mechanisms – the archival content is readily able to be reengaged with, in the ‘now time’ the of the online world and its discourse. The polemical potential and potency is at once overt, engaging and at literally at hand.

Julia Gillard Lalor website

Julia Gillard Federal Member for Lalor 2001 website archived in PANDORA

Election campaigns are certainly highly charged activities and they give rise to many creative (and not so creative) artefacts alongside the more serious documentation of party platforms and promises. By any measure this is material of great political, social and cultural interest. Collecting election campaign material, it being especially ephemeral, has been a fundamental activity of the PANDORA Archive since its inception (as indeed it is of other web archives in other jurisdictions such as the US Library of Congress web archives election collections).

Andrew Wilkie Greens candidate

Andrew Wilkie Greens candidate for Bennelong 2004 website archived in PANDORA before he was elected as the independent member for Denison in 2010.

As a matter of course and with some assiduousness we collect the electoral sites of aspiring candidates. Some of these will disappear never to be heard of on the political scene again, some will pursue a political life perhaps with a variation of direction along the way while some will go on to high office including the prime ministership. It is therefore natural that we have collected the website of the Member for Lalor (Julia Gillard) between 2001 and 2007 – that is commencing a decade before she became Prime Minister. It is natural that we should collect the website of the Member for Griffith (Kevin Rudd) in 2004 and 2006 prior to his terms as Prime Minister. So too it is natural to collect and archive the website of the Member for Warringah (Tony Abbott) from 2001 onwards – a dozen years before he became Prime Minister. Similarly, it is hardly a matter of contention that we should collect, for example, the websites of Malcolm Turnbull as the candidate for the seat of Wentorth and as the Member for Wentworth being a prominent Australian who first appears in the PANDORA archive in association with the 1998 Constitutional Convention and more prominently as the Chairman of the Australian Republican Movement.

Kevin Rudd Member fo Griffith 2004

Kevin Rudd Federal Member for Griffith 2004 website archived in PANDORA

In the first months of 2014, two of the most quoted sources from PANDORA on social media are the Member for Warringah’s website and the Member for Wentworth’s 2009 speech titled 'Time for some straight talking on climate change’ published on his website. The Member for Warringah’s website having been archived between November 2001 and September 2013 obviously provides substantial content to analyse, much as the Prime Minister's book Battlelines will be analysed in respect to the achievments of his tenure in office. In the first quarter of 2014 these two sites entered the top 10 most viewed sites in PANDORA – evidence of the power of word-of-mouth in the guise of the ‘tweet’ – though never really threatening the PANDORA 'pageview' hegemony of the genealogy site First Families 2001 and other stalwarts of popularity such as the Centenary of Federation website, Digger History and the Commonwealth Government’s defunct cultural portal culture.gov.au.

What is evident is that the pursuit of public life and the tenure of public office cultivates a fascinating and fertile field to plough, not only for research but also for the polemic discourse of social media. These men and women (and the organisations which support them) increasingly provide evidence of their journeys to and through public office through the material they publish on the web along the way. Access to this historic material surely helps the Australian citizenry to understand, comment upon and indeed critique their aspiring and achieving leaders. At the risk of over working Milton’s lines from his famous tract the Areopagitica, web archiving may be one of the facilities to enfranchise and ‘give [us] the liberty to know, to utter and to argue freely according to conscience’.

---
The main image used at the heading of this post is from the PANDORA copy (archived July 2013) of the No Fibs website, a 'citizens journalism project' edited by Margo Kingston.

This post appears in our "Web Archiving" blog. To subscribe to future blogposts in these blogs add http://www.nla.gov.au/blogs/web-archiving to your RSS reader. To subscribe to all National Library blogposts, use http://www.nla.gov.au/blogs.

Comments

Comment: 
incvudi<a href=http://www.cabas-sac.com/images/nike/nike20141352.html>sleehak schoenen</a> <a href=http://www.net-contact.com/images/hat/NFL_hat245.html>bonnet en fourrure</a> <a href=http://www.creation-gourmande.fr/images/bags/bags_665_samsonite.html>vrai sac gucci</a> <a href=http://www.cat-cunlhat.com/css/nike/nike2014_1777.html>nike store stockholm</a> <a href=http://www.centre-doussinet.com/css/jordan/jordan20141965.html>visit jordan</a> <a href=http://www.eco-generations.com/images/bags/bags_samsonite53manufacturers.html>sac rouge</a> <a href=http://www.centre-doussinet.com/css/jordan/jordan20141310.html>basketball shoes</a> <a href=http://www.hotel-auvergne-saintroch.com/stats/Jersey/nike_jersey_1667.html>acheter maillot nba</a> <a href=http://www.lesalondemusiques.com/css/christian/christian_656.html>chaussures louboutin dȦgriffȦes</a> <a href=http://www.investir-immobilier.fr/icon/Jersey/nike_jersey_735.html>maillot france exterieur</a> <a href=http://www.espad.fr/images/bags/bags_438_samsonite.html>sac hermes homme</a> <a href=http://www.cat-deneuille.com/images/lv/louis_vuitton_1535.html>louis vuitton louis vuitton</a> <a href=http://www.hotel-auvergne-saintroch.com/stats/Jersey/nike_jersey_3447.html>vente chaussures de sport</a> <a href=http://www.menuiseriesferreyrolles.com/images/hat/NBA_hat1898.html>napapijri bonnet</a> <a href=http://www.plast-up.com/images/hat/bonnet_1815.html>bonnet polaire</a> <a href=http://www.cat-rochefort.com/images/ugg/uggs_van_153.html>ugg cardy</a> <a href=http://www.francoischouchan.fr/images/Glasses/rayban_glass2214.html>rey ban</a> <a href=http://www.francoischouchan.com/images/Glasses/oakley_glasses3279.html>ray ban 4057 polarisé</a> <a href=http://www.carolinemonick.com/images/jrodan/jordan_1399.html>women air jordans</a> <a href=http://www.hotel-auvergne-saintroch.com/images/Glasses/oakley_100_glasses.html>juicy couture country club sunglasses</a> wzoedkoe
Comment: 
lopbtndm eavunjar<a href=http://glassolutions.pl/js/chanel/chanel_louis1734.html>chanel recrutement quiksilver vente en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.evagelosbatteries.gr/js/ralph/Ralph_Lauren175Inch_shirt.html>ralph lauren golf plus</a> <a href=http://eastar.eventshub.sg/js/chanel/chanel_692_Glasses.html>chanel pas cher nike rosche run chaussures de course france boutique</a> <a href=http://www.avanttravel.com/js/michael/michael_pitt_6915.html>michael kors annecy resto toulouse pas cher</a> <a href=http://eastar.eventshub.sg/js/chanel/chanel_366_Glasses.html>chanel grand palais champs élysées</a> <a href=http://www.date4me.co.il/js/michael/michel_431_bags.html>michael kors montre luxe femme</a> <a href=http://chothuevanphonghcm.com.vn/js/hermes/hermes_ashtrays2863.html>hermes montres luxe internet</a> <a href=http://quintessential.chillies.co.za/js/gucci/gucci_2966_bags.html>gucci accessoires aquarium achat</a> <a href=http://www.armasul.pt/js/michael/michael_pitt_6172.html>michael kors watches luxe tv jean stock</a> <a href=http://www.dejvickasokolovna.cz/js/michael/michael_pitt_5971.html>michael kors outlet 123 vêtements boutique en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.dac-uddannelsen.dk/js/michael/michael_hermes286youtube.html>michael kors france guyane en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.ffcasa.co.za/js/ralph/Ralph_Lauren3529Jacket.html>ralph lauren sac papier cadeau</a> <a href=http://www.date4me.co.il/js/michael/michel_5526_bags.html>michael kors paris immobilier atypique à vendre</a> <a href=http://www.democritodummar.art.br/js/michael/michael_pitt_3555.html>michael kors pochette cérémonie pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.321goevents.com/js/Hermes/hermes_1737cm.html>hermes airlines sécurité xl airways</a> <a href=http://www.armasul.pt/js/michael/michael_pitt_6383.html>michael kors wikipedia 5s qualité r5</a> <a href=http://www.alrai.tv/js/nikeH/nike_Air_Max962shoes.html>tmk schoenen</a> <a href=http://www.cellular-iberia.com/js/nikeH/nike_NFL1090Maillots.html>sale schoenen heren</a> <a href=http://www.esquire.co.kr/js/chanel/chanel_meets_3814.html>chanel bijoux luxe grande taille</a> <a href=http://www.amity.edu/js/hermes/hermes_100cm3089.html>hermes bijoux qualité ovulation</a> smrmwjfw gkxsxbog jvtoaowr cjwhdgjo muqjhrhz
Comment: 
jevfnskc mjjfmcuh<a href=http://www.buski.gov.tr/tinymce/examples/LouisVuitton14/6245_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton bijoux redline en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.fantabulousevents.co.za/scripts/LouisVuitton14/4548_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton marrakech en decembre dernier</a> <a href=http://www.ftx.it/public/boots14/4976_boots.html>ugg boots discount accessoires chiens luxe</a> <a href=http://www.anpasemiliaromagna.org/images/longchamp14/3561_longchamp.html>longchamp agenda nancy en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.acmaenterprise.com/public/salomon14/577_salomon.html>salomon running tv a revoir</a> <a href=http://www.businesstransform.co.uk/shoes14/993_shoes.html>jordan 12 weeks pregnancy miracle</a> <a href=http://www.acromondplus.com/UploadFile/JimmyChoo14/4705_boots.html>ugg boots discount rideaux cuisine pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.ftx.it/public/boots14/3601_boots.html>ugg boots enfant 22 mois ne veut plus dormir</a> <a href=http://www.businesstransform.co.uk/shoes14/14646_shoes.html>jordan 11 femme pratique</a> <a href=http://www.arabmu.com/js/hermes/hermes_airport954.html>carre hermes quadrige du grand palais</a> <a href=http://www.cunninghambrick.com/fckeditor/isabelmarant15/517_isabelmarant.html>isabel marant chaussures pas cher lyon</a> <a href=http://www.321goevents.com/js/Hermes/hermes_1562cm.html>hermes sac nike 6.0 pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.amity.edu/js/hermes/hermes_100cm3207.html>hermes airlines s茅curit茅 qualit茅 environnement</a> <a href=http://www.acmaenterprise.com/public/salomon14/495_salomon.html>salomon chaussures running en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.abadgaranejavanksh.com/UserFiles/js/hermes/hermes_2189bags.html>hermes grand palais zuccari</a> <a href=http://www.hfparks.com/css/LouisVuitton14/5323_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton ebay londres pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.champnews.com/js/hermes/hermes_atlanta2402.html>hermes kelly sac quand je serai grand</a> <a href=http://www.boonthavorn.com/LouisVuitton14/5000_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton jeans rg512 pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.alpha-ecc.com/Images/shoes14/16408_shoes.html>jordan 3 quelle wii acheter louer</a> <a href=http://www.ftx.it/public/boots14/4896_boots.html>ugg boots 32 mb expert</a> hpseccca afglmxsp fdbyfili vvlmfhju tcyhyiqi
Comment: 
jmadhomh aorigiqz<a href=http://www.hireatubuk.co.uk/js/gucci/GucciJuicy693_Glasses.html>gucci vente en ligne chaussures</a> <a href=http://www.dabiotechnet.net/js/chanel/chanel_meets_1797.html>chanel recrutement zara en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.dejvickasokolovna.cz/js/michael/michael_pitt_1364.html>michael kors bracelet zirconium pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.afsbirsttr.com/js/nikeH/nike2830-roshe-run.html>nike sneakers sale</a> <a href=http://lojasneusa.com.br/js/chanel/gucci_2827_anything_designer.html>gucci homme d affaire worldcom</a> <a href=http://www.arabmu.com/js/hermes/hermes_airport199.html>hermes recrutement journaliste économique</a> <a href=http://www.acquedottocalcioa5.it/js/nikeH/nike-air-jordan-p207.html>nike schoenen vrouwen</a> <a href=http://www.amity.edu/js/hermes/hermes_100cm1433.html>hermes parfum serge lutens au meilleur prix</a> <a href=http://www.amity.edu/js/hermes/hermes_100cm1687.html>hermes international cours université en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.dongshin.or.kr/js/michael/michael_hermes215youtube.html>michael kors sacs cuir italien pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.cellular-iberia.com/js/nikeH/nike_NFL2374Maillots.html>goedkope sneakers kopen</a> <a href=http://www.avanttravel.com/js/michael/michael_pitt_1155.html>michael kors bijoux pilgrim en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.evagelosbatteries.gr/js/ralph/Ralph_Lauren5218Inch_shirt.html>ralph lauren veste jordan pas cher</a> <a href=http://glassolutions.pl/js/chanel/chanel_louis2511.html>chanel 5 achat maison particulier</a> <a href=http://www.alrai.tv/js/nikeH/nike_Air_Max2677shoes.html>merken sportschoenen</a> <a href=http://www.alhleather.co.uk/js/nikeH/nike-air-jordan-p124.html>mbt schoenen online kopen</a> <a href=http://www.esquire.co.kr/js/chanel/chanel_meets_1008.html>chanel lyon insolite</a> <a href=http://www.date4me.co.il/js/michael/michel_4150_bags.html>michael kors shoes en ligne gratuit</a> <a href=http://www.laptopservice.com/js/gucci/gucci_1697_clothing.html>gucci parfum one million pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.cellular-iberia.com/js/nikeH/nike_NFL1089Maillots.html>nike air max outlet</a> xjiqwsxy ysurmlxk uxsrctdi hakhwrlc lxqzihfy
Comment: 
ipwiuerv lairszoe<a href=http://www.dac-uddannelsen.dk/longchamp14/2376_longchamp.html>longchamp pas cher louboutin homme</a> <a href=http://www.chirocafe.co.kr/images/boots14/5516_boots.html>ugg boots b茅b茅 chat 脿 vendre</a> <a href=http://www.alpha-ecc.com/Images/shoes14/3915_shoes.html>nike store us belle la vie</a> <a href=http://www.abadgaranejavanksh.com/UserFiles/js/hermes/hermes_2537bags.html>hermes pas cher net</a> <a href=http://www.acromondplus.com/UploadFile/JimmyChoo14/3924_boots.html>ugg boots b茅b茅 hotel malakoff pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.amity.edu/js/hermes/hermes_100cm571.html>hermes informatique en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.buski.gov.tr/tinymce/examples/LouisVuitton14/4718_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton luxembourg djerba pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.chirocafe.co.kr/images/boots14/5513_boots.html>ugg boots texto vetement femme en ligne</a> <a href=http://www.dac-uddannelsen.dk/longchamp14/901_longchamp.html>longchamp sac toile quand je serais grand</a> <a href=http://www.businesstransform.co.uk/shoes14/4290_shoes.html>nike store qualit茅 1b</a> <a href=http://www.alpha-ecc.com/Images/shoes14/920_shoes.html>nike air yeezy 2 femme pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.goldmodiin.co.il/smhdata/longchamp14/3108_longchamp.html>longchamp pas cher week end venise</a> <a href=http://www.businesstransform.co.uk/shoes14/14671_shoes.html>jordan 11 concorde de luxe resort</a> <a href=http://www.amity.edu/js/hermes/hermes_100cm401.html>hermes paris insolite et secret</a> <a href=http://www.acromondplus.com/UploadFile/JimmyChoo14/1636_boots.html>ugg boots timberland 2012 un nouveau paradigme</a> <a href=http://www.goldmodiin.co.il/smhdata/longchamp14/3460_longchamp.html>longchamp pliage wrap minceur pas cher</a> <a href=http://www.businesstransform.co.uk/shoes14/15165_shoes.html>air jordan 2012 kia sportage nouveau</a> <a href=http://www.fantabulousevents.co.za/scripts/LouisVuitton14/4521_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton pochette cadeau noel</a> <a href=http://www.arabmu.com/js/hermes/hermes_airport572.html>hermes bijoux en ligne carrefour</a> <a href=http://www.buski.gov.tr/tinymce/examples/LouisVuitton14/1781_louisvuitton.html>louis vuitton wikipedia 3ds pas cher</a> srenikhp nzrgfpyd mtcttsaq dvmudfkp hznogqhk
Comment: 
ductueuzk<a href=http://www.esfahansport.com/css/nikeH/nike1739-roshe-run.html>schoenen voor kids</a> <a href=http://www.consorziomontecampione.it/images/ralph/Ralph_Lauren662Jacket.html>imitation ralph lauren</a> <a href=http://www.drec.or.kr/images/jordan/Jordan_grandes_TaillesJordan1703Hommes.html>jordans 3 shoes</a> <a href=http://www.newld.com/css/ralph/Ralph_Lauren3346Jacket.html>marques de maillot de bain</a> <a href=http://bjqianben.com/js/jordan/Jordan4401Femmes.html>where to buy jordan retro</a> <a href=http://www.chcw.org.za/ralph/Ralph_Lauren3976Jersey.html>polo ralph lauren germany</a> <a href=http://www.drec.or.kr/css/nikeH/nike627-roshe-run.html>online nike sneakers kopen</a> <a href=http://www.atmp.org.br/css/ralph/Ralph_Lauren668Jacket.html>ralph lauren home paris</a> <a href=http://www.cmcaor.org/uploads/ralph/Ralph_Lauren4046Inch_shirt.html>hugo boss store de</a> <a href=http://bjqianben.com/js/jordan/Jordan3789Femmes.html>shoe jordan</a> <a href=http://www.drec.or.kr/images/jordan/Jordan_grandes_TaillesJordan4149Hommes.html>where to buy nike basketball shoes online</a> <a href=http://www.drec.or.kr/css/nikeH/nike1012-roshe-run.html>nike oranje schoenen</a> <a href=http://paolallegrasartorio.com/mdb-db/ralph/Ralph_Lauren4660Jacket.html>veste en simili cuir</a> <a href=http://www.cmcaor.org/uploads/ralph/Ralph_Lauren2241Inch_shirt.html>maillot de bain sundek</a> <a href=http://www.cjcholdings.com/images/nikeH/nike639-roshe-run.html>hardloopschoenen nike</a> <a href=http://paolallegrasartorio.com/mdb-db/nikeR/nike426-roshe-run.html>billiga nike kl?der</a> <a href=http://paolallegrasartorio.com/mdb-db/ralph/Ralph_Lauren748Jacket.html>pulls pas cher homme</a> <a href=http://www.everpure21.com/images/nikeH/nike3003Roshe_Run_Suede.html>goedkope nike air max 90</a> <a href=http://www.cjcholdings.com/css/ralph/Ralph_Lauren3534Jacket.html>soldes vetements hommes</a> <a href=http://www.cmcaor.org/uploads/nikeH/nike1449Roshe_Run.html>nike winkel utrecht</a> xopmvycea

Add new comment